The NFLPA is holding a series of membership-wide conference calls Thursday and Friday to update players around the league on the state of collective bargaining negotiations with the NFL, sources told ESPN.
The sources said Thursday that there are eight calls scheduled — one for each NFL division — and call-in information was distributed to every player in the league, not just the 32 team player representatives. It’s unclear how many players have participated or will participate in the calls, but the union sees this as a chance to speak to its full body of membership about the current CBA offer on the table, as well as the voting procedure by which the deal might eventually be ratified.
The current 10-year CBA proposal includes an option for the NFL to expand its regular season from 16 games to 17 games at some point during the life of the deal (likely sometime between the years 2021 and 2023) while also reducing the number of preseason games and expanding the playoffs to include more teams. Some high-profile player reps have spoken out against the idea of a 17-game season on the grounds that it adds health and safety risks to players in a sport that already includes plenty of them.
Sources familiar with the current proposal say it also includes concessions from the owners’ side on issues such as revenue split, higher minimum salaries, improved player benefits, relaxation of offseason and training camp workout rules, a revised drug policy and others. The questions the players are trying to answer among themselves, the sources said, is whether those concessions are enough to justify an expanded regular season, whether they need to go back to the owners with a counterproposal that asks for more concessions, or whether 17 games is a non-starter no matter what. The NFLPA hopes this week’s conference calls will give it an idea of where a broad cross-section of its members stands on those questions.
No hard deadline has been set for completion of a new CBA, as the current one doesn’t expire until March of 2021. But people on both sides are eager to get the deal done in time for the start of the 2020 league year March 18, so that elements of the new deal can be in place in time for this offseason. The NFL is also set to begin negotiations with its TV broadcast partners on new contracts, and the league and said TV broadcast partners would prefer as clear a picture as possible of the labor landscape before finalizing those deals. If no new CBA deal is reached this offseason, the possibility exists that negotiations could float into next offseason, which raises the possibility of a work stoppage in 2021.
The NFLPA’s rules require a two-thirds vote of its player representatives to approve a new CBA deal before it moves on to the next step, which is a vote by every player in the league. Once the vote gets to the full-membership stage, a simple majority of players is required to ratify the deal. Three-fourths of the league’s owners would then have to vote to approve the deal.
How sports, coronavirus and hygiene mix
The coronavirus pandemic has been a referendum on societal cleanliness. Not just regarding the time spent washing one’s hands or wiping down household surfaces but also going right to the source: bodily fluids.
That includes the kinds found all over the sports world — the spitting, the licking, the spewing, the sweating and, perhaps most disgustingly, the snot rockets, where an athlete takes their hand, closes off one nostril and launches a stream of mucus through the open one.
Indeed, sports are pretty gross. Former MLB pitcher Huston Street, wearing the same baseball cap for months, would lick his hands and rub the brim to create a deep stain of saliva-drenched mud that he’d dab to get a better grip on the ball. “Let me put it this way: Every fluid the body creates has probably, at some point and time, made its way onto a baseball field. Like, during the game,” he told ESPN. “We’re all pretty gross. We’re children.”
When Fran Fraschilla coached NCAA men’s basketball, he would crouch among his players to diagram offensive sets during late-game timeouts and emerge saturated. “Five guys standing over me that were all a foot taller, and the sweat was pouring off of them down onto me like I was in a South American rainforest. That would happen every night,” he said. “Basketball, by its very nature, is kind of gross — large human beings, sweating profusely in their underwear, who are in close proximity to each other.”
It gets even worse. “I threw up in a trash can before every game of my career,” said Mark Schlereth, who played 12 years in the NFL with Washington and Denver. “Every. Single. Game. It was nerves. It was kind of a release. But I did it every game. And once I did it, [former Broncos center] Tommy Nalen would do it, then [former Broncos tackle] Matt Lepsis would do it. Or one of them would start, and then I would throw up. Pretty soon you’ve got all five starters on the offensive line throwing up in one trash can.”
In 2020, amid the coronavirus pandemic? “We would all need our own trash cans if we were playing under the guidelines these guys are going to have,” Schlereth said. “About 20 feet apart. Maybe with our names on them.”
These revolting tales are a part of sports lore, but what happens now? Can sports still be this gross when games are being played during a global pandemic? Fraschilla called basketball “the perfect storm for coronavirus,” but each sport will have numerous concerns in play. How will leagues go about controlling bodily expulsions and secretions?
“What are they going to do? There’s no way to police a sneeze,” Street said.
Welcome to sports in 2020, where cleanliness is going to be next to godliness.
A complicated comeback
The return of sports provokes a series of questions, ranging from the dire to the trivial. Should leagues start up again at all? Multiple MLB games have already been postponed less than a week into the 2020 season after an outbreak of COVID-19 spread throughout the Miami Marlins‘ clubhouse, immediately testing the league’s plans. The debates rage over bringing athletes back into stadiums and arenas for the sake of entertaining empty seats, while more than 149,000 people in the U.S. alone have died from COVID-19, and positive test rates continue to rise in more than a dozen states.
Although 78% of fans polled in July said they would watch games played without fans, the term “opt out” has entered the sports lexicon for athletes. Stars like Ryan Zimmerman of the Washington Nationals, citing family considerations, have chosen not to return to competition. “I have a 3-week-old baby,” Zimmerman said. “My mother has multiple sclerosis and is super high-risk; if I end up playing, I can pretty much throw out the idea of seeing her until weeks after the season is over. There’s a lot of factors that I and others have to consider. I don’t think there’s a right or wrong answer; it’s everybody’s individual choice.”
There are added layers of paranoia for the athletes who contracted COVID-19 and are coming back to compete. Atlanta Braves first baseman Freddie Freeman, a four-time All-Star, said he had a temperature of 104.5 degrees and recalled praying “Please don’t take me” at the height of his symptoms. His return to play came with extra scrutiny, as the Braves and MLB monitored his health.
But sports are coming back. So the next question relates to how to do it safely. Every epidemiologist and medical expert contacted by ESPN indicated that the path forward is one of frequent testing — of everyone involved in the competitions — and securing facilities in a “bubble” that reduces interaction with the general public.
MLB is testing its players every other day during the season and administering antibody tests once a month. The NHL is testing players every day during its season restart. The NBA is testing everyone inside its bubble each night, with results coming back in the morning. The NFL began testing its players each day during the first two weeks of training camp and said it would move to every other day if the positive tests fall below 5%. The WNBA had daily testing as players arrived in its bubble.
“The key thing with the pro sports teams is that they will undoubtedly have the resources to allow themselves to get tested frequently,” Dr. Michael Mina, assistant professor of epidemiology at the Harvard T. H. Chan School of Public Health, told ESPN.
“These are groups of people that undoubtedly will be interacting closely during the game or surrounding the game. I think that because of that, there are populations that are liable to have a lot of spread, to have a virus introduced and to have someone that’s infected get into the population. For these teams to really move forward, and to ensure that they’re all going to be safe, they just need to make sure that they’re not infected when going into practices and games.”
Leagues such as the NBA and NHL that are restarting in a bubble could theoretically succeed in finishing their seasons if protocols are followed, according to Dr. George Rutherford, professor and director of epidemiology and biostatistics at the University of California, San Francisco.
“There are ways you can do it where people are tested with great frequency; that would minimize the risk. But understand that if people are infected, they gotta go out right away,” he said. “As long as you’re testing twice a week, social distancing and wearing masks while in public. They’re going to get infected by other people, not by their benchmates.”
After establishing that sports are coming back and determining the safest way they can come back, the next question is what needs to change about these sports in a COVID-19 world. There’s new information daily about transmission of the coronavirus, but experts are confident that the virus isn’t spread through perspiration. Other bodily fluids are another story.
“There are all sorts of things that go on in sports that are not hygienic. Spitting. Licking things. Getting right up in an official’s face and yelling. Biting. All of those things are unhygienic and risk some kind of disease transmission,” Rutherford said.
In fact, MLB has mandated, among other things, social distancing for players and managers when arguing with umpires: “Players or managers who leave their positions to argue with umpires, come within six feet of an umpire or opposing player or manager for the purpose of argument, or engage in altercations on the field are subject to immediate ejection and discipline, including fines and suspensions.” We got our first viewing of such an encounter this weekend, when Pittsburgh Pirates manager Derek Shelton argued with an umpire while keeping his distance.
As Rutherford said, “There’s more saliva exchanged in a baseball game than there is at a high school dance.”
One of the most enduring clichés in baseball is spitting. Players do it every game. Roseanne Barr did it after her horrific national anthem before a San Diego Padres game in 1990. In the comedy classic “The Naked Gun: From the Files of Police Squad!” players, coaches and fans of the California Angels and Seattle Mariners — and even the players’ wives — hock loogies onto the diamond, with vivid sound design. “Everything we spoof, we love,” writer-director-producer David Zucker told the Los Angeles Times. “We went after every baseball cliché.”
Strands of spit are so woven into the fabric of baseball that expectorating had to be addressed with multiple entries in MLB’s 101-page operations manual for the 2020 season:
“Players are prohibited from spitting, using smokeless tobacco, and sunflower seeds at all times while in Club facilities.”
“[On-field] spitting is prohibited (including but not limited to, saliva, sunflower seeds or peanut shells, or tobacco) at all times in Club facilities (including on the field). Chewing gum is permitted.
“Individuals are prohibited from using spit or sweat to rub baseballs.”
MLB doesn’t specify what the penalties are for any of these infractions in its return-to-play policies.
While the NBA isn’t “prohibiting” spitting, its return-to-play rules state that “at all times on the court, players must avoid spitting.” Across all sports this summer, athletes are reconsidering how much they expel during games.
“I didn’t really know. Do I spit when I play?” asked Mikie Schlosser, a defender for the Denver Outlaws of Major League Lacrosse. “I didn’t really think I spit when I played. Some guys do. It really varies. It’s a high-contact sport. There’s always these fluids being exchanged everywhere.”
What do sports without spitting even look like?
The National Women’s Soccer League was the first pro league in the U.S. to return to play in late June. “We’re not allowed to spit because of coronavirus … but we can’t just not spit,” said forward Paige Nielsen of the Washington Spirit. “So we’re continuing to do that. We’re just doing it more secretively.”
She said that some NWSL players try to distance themselves to unpopulated parts of the pitch before spitting. Despite the necessity for it — Nielsen said players try to create as much saliva as they can to overcome dry throats and breathe more easily — they’re making an effort not to spit, and feeling a little guilty when it happens.
“One time I spit during a game, and I was like, ‘Oh shoot, I’m so sorry.’ But no one really watched me, so I don’t know why I said I was sorry. It’s strange,” Nielsen said with a laugh. “We’re trying to do our part and be responsible.”
It’s not just the players’ spittle at issue.
“Coaches should wear a mask,” said Fraschilla, now a basketball analyst for ESPN. “When coaches get excited, it’s not just the words that come out of your mouth. It could be saliva or other things. And you’re all on top of each other.”
In the NBA, active players and four first-row coaches aren’t required to wear masks. San Antonio Spurs coach Gregg Popovich, 69, told TNT recently that he wears a mask around the bubble, including practice, only taking it off to speak. Masks on the sideline aren’t mandatory for NFL coaching staffs either, though they are strongly recommended by the league. Tampa Bay Buccaneers coach Bruce Arians said, “Once I get a mask and shield on, they won’t have to worry about me spitting.”
MLB requires all individuals in three “tiers” to wear a face covering inside club facilities. (Tier 1 covers players, coaches and team physicians; Tier 2 includes front-office employees and clubhouse staff; those in Tier 3 are people who perform essential services but don’t come in contact with Tier 1 individuals.) The NHL has similar tiers to MLB and is mandating that “face coverings (cloth or surgical-type mask) shall be worn at all times that individuals are outside of their rooms” within the two bubbles in Toronto and Edmonton. That includes within the hotels and around the arena, though masks are not mandated during workouts or, obviously, during games.
According to Dr. Melissa Nolan, an infectious disease expert and professor at the University of South Carolina’s School of Public Health, coaches should check their volume too. “There’s also an interesting article I read that talked about people that loudly talked — the louder the volume of your voice, the more respiratory particles that come out, and the greater chance you can transmit infection. So the coaches that are yelling at first base, the more virus particles they could be expelling versus just making a hand signal,” she said.
Referees make hand signals during a game, but they’re punctuated by using a whistle. While “digital whistles” that are operated by hand are becoming available, the traditional breath-propelled whistle is still the norm. Fraschilla wondered about that in light of COVID-19. “Referee whistles have the saliva come flying out,” he said. “I grew up in a Jewish neighborhood. ‘Schmutz’ is the perfect word.”
How dangerous is the “schmutz”?
Rutherford said he doesn’t believe that spitting is a significant threat for COVID-19 transmission. “This is a respiratory virus. If you cough or sneeze, it could clearly be transmitted. But spitting, per se? Highly unlikely. Unless someone ran their fingers through it and stuck it in their eyes,” he said. “But here’s a chance to inject some civility, you know? How about a cup [for the seeds]? How about pretending that the floor of the dugout couldn’t be washed out by a fire hose and that it was really your in-laws’ carpet?”
Nolan, on the other hand, offered some concern about seed spitting. She said that spitting “puts the virus in the environment” of a game setting “if there are virus particles living on the saliva” being expelled.
“When I think about the grosser aspects, like spitting sunflower seeds … well, those sunflower seeds could contain infectious particles on them,” Nolan told ESPN. “I would think the bigger risk of getting infected is that the janitorial staff comes to clean it up, touches it with their hands when scooping it up, and then touches their face. Anything that has to do with saliva or spit could, in theory, transmit infection.”
That would include licking, much to the chagrin of Drew Brees.
“The whole point is to help give your hands a little tackiness so you get better grip on the ball,” Brees said. “I’ve actually been thinking about it a lot lately as I’ve started throwing again. Trying to avoid it, but it has been so habitual for so long. You don’t realize how much you touch your face and lick your fingers until COVID hit.”
Ryan Harris, an offensive lineman for seven years in the NFL, didn’t need a pandemic to loathe finger licking. “It’s so gross, even when there isn’t COVID,” he said. “And just look where he puts his hands the play before, the play after, and the play he’s running when he licks his fingers. Do the math. Honestly, there are a lot of every-day, don’t-give-it-a-second-thought things people are going to have to give a second thought about.”
For instance, prior to this, pitchers never gave licking their hands a second thought. It’s as inherent a part of their routines as shaking off a sign from the catcher.
Street was one of the most notorious hand-lickers in baseball during his career, one that included 324 saves over 13 seasons. As a relief pitcher, he entered the game when the chalk-covered game balls at the bottom of the bag were being put in play.
“You lick the ball, you throw the ball, you hit the ball,” Street said. “I don’t know if the grass brushes it off or whatnot, but if someone picks it up, the outfielders have been licking their hands in between pitches. You grab the ball and then you lick your hand again. So I would imagine we’re all exchanging something, somehow. There are a billion ways for this virus to go around and around beyond spitting seeds.”
It’s yet to be seen how the NFL will handle hand licking in its season, but the NBA and MLB have prohibited it, with the latter having implanted the now-infamous “wet rag” rule. According to the rule, “All pitchers may carry a small wet rag in their back pocket to be used for moisture in lieu of licking their fingers. Water is the only substance allowed on the rag. Pitchers may not access the rag while on the pitching rubber and must clearly wipe the fingers of his pitching hand dry before touching the ball or the pitcher’s plate. Umpires will have the right to check the rag at any point.” Pitchers were also instructed to bring their own rosin bag to the mound.
MLB additionally states that “any baseball that is put in play and touched by multiple players shall be removed and exchanged for a new baseball. After an out, players are strongly discouraged from throwing the ball around the infield.”
Not everyone is on board with the extensive measures. Though he hasn’t played since 2017, Street sarcastically wondered, “If I pitch a baseball, at what spin rate does COVID fly off the baseball? Now that’s an interesting study. We can reinvent the game. Once spin rate drops to a certain level for a pitcher, and COVID can stay on the ball, then you have to pull the pitcher. Mandatory pitcher substitution for the health and safety of the players. It would be like, ‘I know you’re a really good closer, but sorry, the COVID sticks on the ball too well for you.'”
Skepticism aside, Nolan says she believes that if not for proper cleaning, equipment like balls and bats would be a major risk factor in restarting sports in a pandemic. “Very bad news. That I’d say would be a big risk,” she said. “That’s why we think gyms are going to be a hotbed. By working out you’re shedding more virus, you’re breathing heavier and harder. Combine that with stainless steel and plastic materials, which are the ones where the virus can live on the longest and the best.”
That’s why the NBA had team staff clean basketballs after team workouts with dish soap and water, letting them dry and then spraying them with a disinfectant. Along with asking players to avoid spitting, the league has asked players to avoid licking hands, unnecessary touching of mouthguards and “clearing your nose” while on the court.
That’s right: COVID-19 could mean the end of one of sports’ greatest, grossest traditions: the snot rocket.
Benn, of the NHL’s Canucks, said it’s not mandatory that he launch snot rockets into the atmosphere. It has just become a natural part of his routine.
“You’re breathing heavy after almost every shift. You come off the ice, sit on the bench, clear your runways, take a sip of water and then you get back out there,” he said.
The NHL’s return-to-play protocols don’t specifically call out spitting, licking or “snot rockets” like baseball and basketball do, other than asking players to use tissues for a sneeze.
“I’m not going to put my stick down, take my gloves off and ask the trainer, ‘Can I have a tissue?’ That’s just not going to happen,” Benn said. “If they tell us we can’t do it, the entire league and every guy is just going to do it anyway. I think it’s going to be too hard to police. Guys aren’t going to be thinking about it. It just comes so naturally.”
Harris recalled firing snot rockets “every day” on the field during his NFL career. “I shot them like crazy. Clear your nose and play on. If you can’t snot rocket, you can’t breathe. Do that with a full COVID facemask, and that’s a habit that’s going to be an issue,” he said, referencing the Oakley-designed face coverings that could be headed to the NFL.
Nielsen said snot rockets have their place on the pitch as well. “When I’m on the soccer field, it’s very normal,” she said. “Especially in March when it’s preseason and it’s cold in D.C. and you’ll see it flying everywhere. Your hands are so cold that you can’t even grab a tissue, and you’re in the middle of the play and you can’t breathe. You just have to. You have to clear your airways.”
But the snot rocket during a pandemic? “I’ve actually seen players, after they have a snot rocket, kind of step on it. I don’t know if this helps at all. But they try to bury it into the ground,” she said.
Every little bit counts when dealing with mucus, which has a much higher viral load than saliva. “[Snot rockets are] not going to be good,” Rutherford warned. “That’s seriously uncool. We’re not talking hygiene there. If you somehow got that on your finger and then rubbed that in your eye or nose, you could certainly get infected.”
Nolan added, “If you have some kind of aspirant, like phlegm, it’s super rich with virus. You’re much more likely to get infected by snot versus spit. So no more snot rockets. C’mon boys, listen to your mother.”
Spitting. Licking. Snot rocketing. Moms frown upon them all, but all have been indelible parts of the sports experience. Perhaps that changes during a global pandemic, thanks to league protocols and an increased self-awareness about unhygienic behavior. Or perhaps sports are just gross and will instinctually remain so during games.
“It’s almost funny for me that we’re taking all of these precautions on the field, but once you put your gear on, all bets are off,” said Schlosser of MLL. “You’re not going to think any differently about how you’re going to play or what you’re going to do.
“Most of the guys I talk to on my team … we just want to play. We’re already risking exposure. And I don’t mind that risk, doing something that I love and doing something I’m compensated for. That’s the conclusion we’ve come to.”
ESPN’s Jeff Passan, Jeff Legwold, Mike Triplett and Jesse Rogers provided additional reporting for this story.
Don’t expect NFL training camp holdouts in 2020
Dalvin Cook showed up for work Tuesday, on the day the Minnesota Vikings were scheduled to report to training camp. No, the running back does not yet have the new contract extension he wants. And no, in spite of the threat he reportedly made in June, there was never really a chance he was going to hold out of camp either way.
The traditional training camp holdout by a player entering the final year of his contract is not something you can expect to see much this year, and it has nothing to do with the coronavirus pandemic. The reason camp holdouts are mostly a thing of the past is what the league’s new collective bargaining agreement, approved in March by owners and players, says about them. Here’s the exact text in Article 8, Section 1(b):
A player shall not receive an Accrued Season for any League Year in which the player is under contract to a Club and in which (i) he failed to report to the Club’s preseason training camp on that player’s mandatory reporting date; or (ii) the player thereafter failed to perform his contract services for the Club for a material period of time, unless he demonstrates to the Impartial Arbitrator extreme personal hardship causing such failure to report or perform, such as severe illness or death in the family.
This was a priority for the owners in the last round of CBA talks. They wanted to stiffen penalties for training camp holdouts, and they did. The previous CBA stipulated that players could lose an accrued season only if they didn’t show up to camp by the date 30 days before the team’s first regular-season game. So, in Cook’s case, that date would have been Aug. 14. Under the new CBA, it was Tuesday.
Why does this matter? Losing an accrued season affects a player’s free-agency status. As a 2017 draft pick, Cook has accrued three seasons so far, and he needs four to be eligible for unrestricted free agency. If he didn’t earn an accrued season for 2020, then next March he’d only be a restricted free agent, meaning the Vikings would have the right to match any offer he got from another team.
Now, even when the mandatory reporting date was later under the old rules, this didn’t stop everyone. For example, last year, Cowboys running back Ezekiel Elliott held out well past that 30-days-before-the-season mark as he headed into his fourth year, which meant that if he would have hit free agency this past March he would have been a restricted free agent instead of an unrestricted one. Elliott didn’t care, figuring his accomplishments over his first three seasons — i.e., leading the league in rushing yards twice and in rushing yards per game in the other year — would prevent restricted free agency from limiting his market. It didn’t matter in the end, because he signed an extension with the Cowboys right before the season.
But a player like Cook, even as great as he is, can’t assume the same thing Elliott could. Cook has missed 19 games because of injury in his three-year NFL career, and even if he were to put together an outstanding and healthy season, there’s no way to be sure a team would be willing to outbid the Vikings for him and part with a second-round draft pick.
So Cook is there, as Joe Mixon almost certainly will be in Cincinnati and Alvin Kamara in New Orleans and George Kittle in San Francisco and all of the other guys who are going into the final years of their contracts and want new ones will be in the cities in which their teams play. Holding out a couple of days into camp carries a stiffer penalty than it ever used to carry, and it doesn’t make sense unless you’re a star quarterback or someone who can feel confident that restricted free agency wouldn’t, well, restrict you.
Three other things to know about this new CBA feature:
Don’t expect any “hold-ins,” either. There are some around the league who believe a player in Cook’s situation would show up for camp and just refuse to practice until a new deal is hammered out. It’s possible, but go back and reread Article 8, Section 1(b) again and note where it says, “the player thereafter failed to perform his contract services for the Club for a material period of time.” That’s the part that would allow the team to dock the player an accrued season if he showed up and refused to practice or take part in mandatory team activities. Could a player in Cook’s situation claim an injury? Sure. But if the team didn’t believe him, or diagnose him as injured, the matter could end up in front of an arbitrator, who could rule in the team’s favor and deny the player an accrued season.
Fines are stiffer, but not for Cook, Mixon, Kamara or Kittle. The new CBA raised the maximum fine for skipping training camp from $40,000 per day to $50,000 per day, but fines for players who are still on their rookie contracts are capped at $40,000 per day as long as they’re not in their fifth-year option season. Any player drafted in 2017 is entering the fourth year of his rookie deal, so his fines stay at $40,000 per day if he skipped days. Not that it matters much, since the threat of losing an accrued season probably acts as a more significant deterrent.
Fines can still be waived, if you’re on your rookie deal. Customarily, when players have held out of camp and ultimately agreed to new deals, the team has tended to waive the camp holdout fines. There is a new rule in the CBA that prohibits teams from doing that. In Article 42, Section 1(vi) and 1(vii) it reads, “Any such fines shall be mandatory, and shall not be reduced in amount or waived by the Club, in whole or in part, but must be paid by the player or deducted by the Club.” But that wording doesn’t appear in Sections 1(viii) or 1(ix), which are the ones that deal with players on their rookie contracts. For players who are still on their rookie deals, teams are still permitted (though obviously not required) to forgive camp holdout fines. If a veteran player such as, say, DeAndre Hopkins, were to hold out, his team would not be allowed to waive his fines.
25 years after debut, Panthers and Jaguars are back to rebuilding – Jacksonville Jaguars Blog
Nobody knew exactly what to expect schematically from the NFL’s first expansion teams since 1976, when Seattle and Tampa Bay came into the league. Nobody knew exactly what to expect in terms of playcalling and decision-making from Carolina’s Dom Capers and Jacksonville’s Tom Coughlin, both NFL head coaches for the first time.
It was so raw that the opening kickoff was delayed almost three minutes because the teams lined up on the wrong side of the field.
“Really? I don’t remember that,” said then-Jaguars starting quarterback Steve Beuerlein, who signed a three-year deal a year later to play for Carolina, the organization he said he wanted to play for all along after being the first pick of the expansion draft. “I do remember Tom Coughlin wanted to win that game very badly.
“It was like the Super Bowl. He wanted to establish dominance right away.”
The game, a 20-14 Carolina victory, meant nothing in terms of what would happen that season.
It meant everything in terms of bragging rights.
The organizations had been compared ad nauseam since the NFL in the fall of 1993 awarded Carolina the 29th franchise and Jacksonville the 30th. Every move, from the expansion draft to the college draft to free agency, was dissected and debated.
“The media was all riled up about it, but we didn’t give a damn,” said Hall of Fame executive Bill Polian, Carolina’s first general manager. “We were trying to build the best Panthers team we could. Other than the Hall of Fame or the Super Bowl, we weren’t going to play them.”
Carolina founding owner Jerry Richardson didn’t hide from pressure, promising to win a Super Bowl within the organization’s first 10 years. They almost did, getting to the NFC Championship Game in the second season and reaching the Super Bowl in 2003 and again in 2015.
Jacksonville, which also made the AFC Championship Game in its second season, is still looking for its first trip to the Super Bowl.
Comparisons of the franchises aren’t as prevalent today. But on this anniversary, let’s take a look at how they’ve done as their inaugural game reaches its silver anniversary:
Carolina got off to a faster start, winning an expansion-record seven games in 1995 and going 12-4 in the second season because of a more veteran roster. That was key for an organization building a new stadium for the 1996 season and trying to sell permanent seat licenses.
Jacksonville had a 49-38 advantage after five seasons as the Panthers got old fast and the younger Jaguars roster came into its own.
But in terms of consistency, despite never posting consecutive winning seasons, the Panthers have been far and away better.
Best NFL team since 1995: Patriots (.703) | Worst NFL team since 1995: Browns (.303)
Jaguars: 176-224 (.440). Ranks 25th among 32 teams.
Best year: The Jaguars had the best record in the NFL in 1999 (14-2) and demolished Miami 62-7 in a divisional playoff (that turned out to be the last game for Dan Marino and Jimmy Johnson) to set up an AFC title game rematch against Tennessee. The Titans, who were the only team to beat the Jaguars in the regular season, won again in Jacksonville 33-14.
Worst year: The Jaguars went 2-14 in 2012 — losing eight games by double digits — but still ended up with the second overall pick in the 2013 draft because Kansas City also went 2-14 but had a weaker strength of schedule.
Panthers: 195-204-1 (.489). Ranks 16th since 1995.
Best year: Hands down the 2015 season, when Carolina won its first 14 games, finished the regular season 15-1 and didn’t suffer its second loss until a 24-10 setback to Denver in Super Bowl 50. Quarterback Cam Newton won the league MVP and became iconic with his celebratory dab and sometimes outrageous style.
Worst year: Again, an easy one. 2001. Rookie quarterback Chris Weinke engineered a 24-13 victory against his hometown Vikings and the Panthers went on to lose their final 15 games, something no NFL team before or since has done.
Both teams had solid initial success, making the playoffs in their second seasons. Neither have achieved the ultimate prize. The Panthers came close twice.
Best since 1995: Patriots (20) | Worst since 1995: Browns (1)
Jaguars: 7 (ranks tied for 21st since 1995)
Panthers: 8 (ranks tied for 18th since 1995)
Matt Rhule this past offseason became the fifth coach in Carolina history. The Jaguars, in Doug Marrone, have their sixth coach, and they’ve had four since 2011.
Best since 1995: Steelers (2) | Worst since 1995: Raiders (12)
Jaguars: 5 full-time coaches (ranks tied for ninth since 1995)
Panthers: 4 (ranks tied for fourth since 1995)
As New England proved with Tom Brady, having a franchise quarterback long-term is key to consistency, something neither the Panthers nor Jaguars have had for the most part. Carolina released its initial franchise quarterback, 1995 first-round pick Kerry Collins, four games into his fourth season, with alcohol abuse a factor.
Best since 1995: Patriots and Packers (3 QBs who started eight games or more) | Worst since 1995: Browns (18)
Jaguars: 7 (started eight games or more)
Best: Mark Brunell (63-54 record, 25,698 yards)
Worst: Blaine Gabbert (5-22, 4,357 yards)
Panthers: 9 (started eight games or more)
Best: Cam Newton (68-55-1 record, 29,041 yards)
Worst: Chris Weinke (2-17, 3,800 yards)
Advantage: Tie. The Jaguars had less turnover, but the Panthers had two quarterbacks that led them to Super Bowls in Newton and Jake Delhomme. Brunell doesn’t get the credit he deserves as a QB and playmaker because he never threw for more than 20 TDs in a season. Blame Coughlin for that because the Jaguars turned to James Stewart, Natrone Means and Fred Taylor when they got inside the 10-yard line. Fun fact: Current Jaguars QB Gardner Minshew started 12 games as a rookie last season and already has more career victories with the Jaguars (six) than Gabbert and Chad Henne (5-17).
This isn’t close. Recently retired Carolina linebacker Luke Kuechly was named first-team All-Pro five times.
Best since 1995: Ravens (15) | Worst since 1995: Washington (1)
Jaguars: 5 (ranks tied for 27th since 1995)
Honor roll: CB Jalen Ramsey, RB Maurice Jones-Drew, CB Rashean Mathis, LB Kevin Hardy, T Tony Boselli
Panthers: 13 (ranks 3rd since 1995)
Honor roll: RB Christian McCaffrey, LB Luke Kuechly, CB Josh Norman, QB Cam Newton, LB Jon Beason, C Ryan Kalil, LB Thomas Davis, G Evan Mathis, T Jordan Gross, DE Julius Peppers, DT Kris Jenkins, WR Steve Smith, WR Muhsin Muhammad
This benchmark uses Pro Football Reference.com’s Approximate Value ranking, which puts a seasonal value of a player at any position from any year. This number represents the average of their draft picks since 1995.
Best since 1995: Colts (50.4) | Worst since 1995: Browns (18.1)
Jaguars: 28.3 (ranks 20th)
Panthers: 35.6 (ranks 7th)
The Panthers had an MVP in 2015 with Newton and have had five other major award winners (offensive/defensive players of the year, rookies of the year, coaches of the year). Newton was also offensive player of the year in 2015, Kuechly was defensive player of the year in 2013, Rivera was coach of the year in 2015 and Capers was coach of the year in 1996.
The Jaguars have been shut out in major on-field awards since 1995.
Best since 1995: Colts (9) | Worst since 1995: Browns and Jaguars (0)
Panthers: 6 (tied for fifth)
Both organizations are in rebuilding mode. Both are going young, although rebuilding in different ways. Carolina is going with a first-year NFL coach in Matt Rhule, a 30-year-old offensive coordinator in Joe Brady and a quarterback in Teddy Bridgewater who has the daunting task of replacing Newton.
The Jaguars are sticking with Marrone, who coached the Jaguars to the AFC title game in 2017 but has won 11 games since, and giving 2019 sixth-rounder Minshew the chance to prove he can be the long-term starter.
Frank Garcia, a rookie center 25 years ago, believes the 1995 Panthers might have been more talented than the current team. There’s no question that roster was more experienced or that Capers had more NFL experience than Rhule, who has spent one season in the league.
It was Capers that held things together during an 0-5 start in 1995 so the organization could win 20 of its next 27 games, including the playoffs.
“Dom positively, through those first five losses, was just an absolute game-changer for everybody,” Garcia said. “I never will cease to respect and admire how he handled that.”
Rhule has job security with a seven-year, $62 million deal, so he can take his time rebuilding. Jaguars owner Shad Khan is giving Marrone, as well as general manager Dave Caldwell, a chance to prove they can turn the franchise around without Coughlin looking over their shoulders (Khan fired Coughlin in December). But how much patience will Khan have after seven losing seasons in his eight years as owner?
Neither organization is expected to compete for a playoff spot this year, so expectations are as low now as they were in 1995 and 1996, when both teams exceeded expectations and made deep playoff runs.
As was the case then, the organizations are taking different approaches.
“There were very few similarities between the two,” Beuerlein recalled of the first few years of both franchises. “It just shows there’s a bunch of different ways to do it.”
A-League 2020: Perth Glory v Adelaide United, live, blog, start time, stream, scores,
Transfer news LIVE: Havertz to Chelsea latest, Man Utd target Sancho's Liverpool twist
Jadon Sancho to Man Utd: Star wants Liverpool transfer, Woodward eyes swap, contract terms
Chelsea could force Arsenal to make key Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang transfer decision
Chelsea Kai Havertz transfer expected to block second deal for Frank Lampard
Premier League transfers 2020, Wilfried Zaha wants to leave Crystal Palace, cost, fee, news, EPL
Liverpool could cherry-pick five relegated stars if they repeat successful transfer tactic
Chelsea suffer huge transfer blow as Bayer Leverkusen reject Kai Havertz demand
Man Utd chief Ed Woodward draws up two-week transfer plan that will affect Chelsea plans
Is eight games too harsh? Breaking down Los Angeles Dodgers reliever Joe Kelly’s suspension
NFL5 days ago
Chiefs’ Laurent Duvernay-Tardif always knew he’d choose between football and medicine – Kansas City Chiefs Blog
Soccer5 days ago
Liverpool owners FSG could veto Jurgen Klopp on one striker signing
Soccer2 days ago
Aston Villa end of season player ratings: Grealish, Mings, Luiz shine but one ace gets 3
Soccer1 day ago
Chelsea urged to avoid Arsenal transfer mistake and sign 'naturally-gifted' Man City star
NBA1 day ago
Players debuting in bubble still eligible for Rookie of the Year in ’21
Cricket7 days ago
England, West Indies to compete for Richards-Botham Trophy as Wisden closes the book
Cricket5 days ago
Cricket South Africa unveils plans to tackle racism in the sport
Soccer7 days ago
Fantasy Premier League tips: Seven transfers to consider for Gameweek 38+